Originally published at: NTSB Releases Preliminary Report on Delta A330 Turbulence Encounter - AVweb
New details describe the sequence of events and injuries aboard Flight 56.
As a retired ATC familiar with radar weather display on ATC scopes, I can’t fathom a controller not seeing on his radar what is shown on the image in this report, and not issuing a vector around that big red spot. Maybe a current radar controller can explain the discrepancy?
There is zero accountability for controllers that do a terrible job.
1 Like
Yes, the controller can issue an advisory but it’s the pilot’s job to fly the plane. By that, I’m saying look out the window and use your radar. With that kind of pre-departure weather brief, I’d be monitoring my radar all the time.
Mac, a few years back, was IFR and was given an assigned heading to fly, I read back the heading. I flew as directed and it became very rough, I then was handed off to another controller. When I checked in, the controller exclaimed, that she didn’t know why I had been assigned that heading as it was heading me directly into a thunderstorm. She gave me a new heading to fly out of the turbulence.
This is clearly on the flightcrew. At that altitude and in that airspace they could have asked for deviations in any direction, to avoid the convective activity they ended up flying into, and ATC would have approved it. There are several sources of information available to a flightcrew regarding convective activity along their route of flight. Modern aircraft have excellent on board weather radar and Part 121 carriers, like Delta, have a dispatcher monitoring each flight, providing updates on their routing including sending sigmets and ride reports. Armed with that information the crew would then tell ATC how they wanted to avoid the weather ahead. The NTSB report stated the crew flew through the area with the heaviest, all red, radar returns. Maybe they thought they could top it, but that is almost always a very bad idea. The fact that they didn’t have the seatbelt sign on is also very hard to understand . Since this flight had an augmented crew it will be interesting to find out who was actually on the flightdeck when this happened. In any case the responsibility for operating this flight rests solely with the flightcrew, not ATC.