Originally published at: FAA Shields Voluntary Safety Reports
New order protects certain safety information shared by industry groups to encourage voluntary reporting.
I don’t see what is new here. This is only an order saying, obey 14 CFR 193, which has been around for over a decade. If we really want to improve safety and open up safety data for sharing, Congress need to pass a law (for all industries) that safety data is protected from litigation so long as a company performs due diligence on the hazards identified in the data to reduce risk. If a company sits on data and does not assess its risk or mitigate unacceptable risk, then the information can be used in a court of law.
There is a law to prevent public disclosure of cockpit voice recordings that go to the NTSB. Somehow a court ordered disclosure anyway of the recordings of the Lexington KY crash where the plane departed on the wrong runway, even though those were supposed to be for NTSB use only. Any law requiring confidentiality can be worked around by judges. People won’t disclose safety issues if they think they will be dragged into a lawsuit, just like companies not making improvements if it exposes them to liability lawsuits.
“Still, the designation nonetheless excludes information involving possible criminal activity, intentional falsification, reckless conduct, substance abuse and certain other misconduct.”
The ASAP program also has what is known internally, in the Voluntary Safety Program, as the “Big 5” exclusions for not accepting a report.
Airmen should be entitled to anonymity to encourage reporting of safety issues. All other’s, such as VDRP and USAST, dilute the safety risk management principles.
The NTSB’s data isn’t national security classified. The law is highly specific and it is judges who determine what the law is, not federal bureaucrats. It seems likely to me that the judge here issued a confidentiality order as to the recordings. If the recordings aren’t for public disclosure, they still aren’t, and therefore use of the recordings is consistent with the law.
This topic was automatically closed after 7 days. New replies are no longer allowed.